Which map choosing method would be more user friendly?

[BillB1ox (Will)]

I am currently working on cross-server matchmaking based on MatchmakingService, and I am currently adding in the map solution.

So I have 2 possible ways for players to choose maps.

1. Players choose a map, and using Random.new(), I will choose a map from all of the selected maps
2. In the lobby, players will click multiplayer, then the map they choose, and expect to be paired up with people who want the same map.

Which would be better?

• Option 1
• Option 2

And if you have additional feedback, please let me know down below!
Thanks in advance!

[Crazedbrick1]

I’m against option 2, since that may promote unfair teaming in many servers. Option 1 sounds the best so each player can get a healthy mix of different maps.