Which map is best?

About

Hi! So I bought some assets and wanted to make a few simulator maps/layouts with them. Note that they are just layouts and more will be added I am mainly focusing on the central area. Map#2 was made by @coneylove133

Map#1

Map#2

Map#3

I personally don’t like the first one as much because it is very enclosed when simulator maps are typically very open.

Polls

Which Map is the best in your opinion?

  • Map #1
  • Map #2
  • Map #3

0 voters

2 Likes

Map 1:

As you mentioned, it is too compact. This layout would do well in a roleplaying game but not so much in a simulator.

Map 2:

Everything is seen by the player in one glance which is nice. The spot in the center could also be a hub for trading or the like for the game.

Map 3:

It feels so, unnatural? Everything is on one side that it feels like a movie set.

Conclusion:

Map 2 is simply the best one out of the three. Although it could do some improvements (having some buildings higher than others; rarely-used buildings behind other buildings for depth.

4 Likes