Which one is better?

I had a friend design a UI for me, but I don’t seem to support it much. I need opinions

Original

Screenshot 2024-04-11 182537

Redesign

image

Context: This a button tycoon game about bottles; It is cartoony-themed.

Game Environment

RobloxScreenShot20240411_183035629
RobloxScreenShot20240411_183041165

Factory Environment 1

RobloxScreenShot20240411_183219887
RobloxScreenShot20240411_183158387
RobloxScreenShot20240411_183203888
RobloxScreenShot20240411_183213417

Factory Environment 2

RobloxScreenShot20240411_183132104
RobloxScreenShot20240411_183113225
RobloxScreenShot20240411_183118743
RobloxScreenShot20240411_183126682

Should I combine the two styles? or use one of them?

3 Likes

Personally, Original one looks like old classic game UI style
I think Redesign one looks better for tycoon game/ cartoon style game!

5 Likes

I like the new GUI’s style but I don’t like it’s color. I would say to use the old gui’s color and the newer one’s style. The builds looks good as they are.

1 Like

Both look really good and simple.

I think tweaking the Layout would make it look better.

1 Like

You should add a little padding to the ‘+’ icon in the redesigned UI. Other than that, it looks good.