Which one is better?

[ZINTICK (ZILLY)]

these are both going to be tool icons most probably used in enventry and loot boxes but i have two varying styles of which i dont know what to choose or my future players would like
FIRST

ignore the image quality all images will be sized down so detail doesnt matter to much

the second one may look better rn but just zoom but of them to the same size.

[ZINTICK (ZILLY)]

• First
• Second

which is better?

btw this is using the second ones method

[GamEditoPro]

First is better due to that white shine, instead of plain yellow like on the second image.

[ZINTICK (ZILLY)]

Ok do u think these two items would fit with each other like do they have the same style - ish

[GamEditoPro]

Style is same, but trowel won’t fit due to it’s handle coloring. No correct shade.