Which Portal Looks Better?

I’m making an obby and I made two portal concepts. At the end of every 100 stages or so you enter the portal and it brings you to the next 100 stages. This is an obby so the portals need to be simplistic. Which looks better for a cartoony mega obby?

Portal 1 is on the left and portal 2 is on the right

Edit: I forgot to add a pole

Which Portal Looks Better?
  • Portal 1 (Left)
  • Portal 2 (Right)

0 voters

2 Likes

I think the left looks better, but only because it is more uniform than the right.

The left has a 45~ degree angle on both the inside and outside of the portal frame, in the same direction, whereas portal 2 has an inversely curved frame.

The right portal might look more appealing if you also curve the top corners inwards with Unions or Meshes, like this:

I think this design is a bit more eye-catching as it is more complex than the straight angle, it is curved, this also makes it feel more cartoony to me.
It also might suit some themes better than others, if your obby has a theme.

3 Likes

It depends on what style of game are you going for, if your going for more of a fun game, with low poly assets, go to the one on the right. If your looking for a simple game, go with the one on the left

1 Like

The left portal looks way better than the right one.