Which Shading Style is the Most Appealing? | Pixel Art

Hello all! I’ve been experimenting with different pixel art shading styles and would like to know what is most appealing from a consumer’s perspective. Ex. Someone looking to commission this.

1:
Untitled24_20220307230911
2.
Untitled24_20220307230918
3.
Untitled24_20220307230922

  • Image 1
  • Image 2
  • Image 3

0 voters

Thanks!

5 Likes

Honestly image 1 seems best as the shine on the apple isn’t too large.

2 Likes

Image 1 appeals to me the most.

2 Likes

Image 1 is more appealing due to the shine not being as large and in general just looks better.

1 Like

I personally really like number 2. It’s a unique shading style that reminds of the dithering effect in really old images

1 Like

I picked Image 1 since the shading style seems more clean.

1 Like

If your game has a somewhat horrific style then pick image 2. If your game is normal then pick image 1.

I must say these pixel arts is pretty damm good! Great jog!

3 Likes

I see Image 1 has won by a long shot. Thank you everyone for voting and/or replying! It helps a lot!

Thanks!

I guess this was one of the things people liked about it, but didn’t intend for it to be smaller lol just an accident.

Okay! I see what all of you mean.