I am doing a flat UI design, I made two versions and I can’t decide which one is better, I would like you to say which one you think is better, I would also like some feedback:
Thanks.
8 Likes
I personally think the second one is better, But both look great.
3 Likes
I personally think the bottom one is better. It flows much more consistently than the top UI and has no awkward division. Also, did you make these yourself?
6 Likes
I made them, with rbxasset://textures/ui/ textures, I like how clean the first one is, but I think it is less consistent, any advice to improve it?
You haven’t seen them with animations hehe, but I don’t make commissions.
Personally, I prefer the second, it looks more modern as the bending of the ui into itself helps imporving the look if it and make it look like effort was put into it. Meanwhile, the first one looks like a quick combination of 3 parts, background, top bar, and the closing icon.
Overall, its a personal opinion which might differ from a person to another.
1 Like
These look really nice! I think the bottom one is better though, I love the whole look of it.
2 Likes
I tried. Lmao!
I tried to remake yours but, yeah yours is better than mine!
1 Like
I personally like the top one, as it seems more cartoonish overall and fits the general style. These both look great, and I can’t wait to see the finished product!
The bottom one for sure, the top bar is much more clearly separated from the white background.
In the first one. I tried to make the effect that the white background is above the top bar, quite the opposite of second design. I think what I like least is the close button, if I take it off it looks much better:
1 Like
It reminds me of a closed folder icon
The idea itself is pretty good, but did you try using the topbar from example 2 with the white background elevation from example 1?
Maybe get rid of the bubbleish shape for the “X” and make it straight on the left like the bottom is.
1 Like
I prefer the second one, as it’s crisp, clean lines and larger shadows appeal and attract me more. Granted, I do not have the same opinion as everyone but the second just calls to me more. However though, in all, they’re both great! Better than anything I could’ve done.
Second one looks better, the X button looks perfect on it, the first one looks off.
I think the bottom one is better. Because it look comfortable for a game like that
I personally believe the bottom one is better, as it add’s a lot more depth and life into the UI, and overall a more crisp look!
personally prefer the second, but the drop shadow for the text is either too low or not dark enough.
solid and sleek design!!