Which version of this game icon is better?

I’ve hired a guy to draw me a nice game icon but I can’t decide how I want to put some graphics over it. Which one of these is best? Is there a better way? (btw this art isn’t quite finished)
1:

2:

3:

4:


5:

5 Likes

1 mostly because it pops out more

but the title in roblox is right below that too.

Yeah 1 is the most appealing icon. I would have that icon on, and no more than a month or two later, I would get rid of the “NEW” letters from the top right and leave it alone or maybe add “Update” to it.

1 is better but maybe consider changing the color of the 2 so it stands out more

1 and 3.

Gotta add text, so you know what game you are about to play!

Five is the best, the title does not need to be shown twice.