Who is better ? GFX feedback

I made police style GFX with two different lighting


11 Likes

Nice stuff, personally think #2 is nicer by a long shot as the inclusion of shadows adds a bit more definition to the whole image and it draws more focus on them.

4 Likes

I prefer #2 since it shows more detail.
Although if your game is called something like Night Cops it may not fit the game properly.

If you want a darker theme like #1 then maybe you could move the lighting angle a bit to see where the most detail from the least light is to show the fronts of the uniforms better.

4 Likes

Both of these GFXs look good. The one on the bottom looks way better though because of the lighting.

2 Likes

1st one is a lot more realistic and practical when you’ll come to editing and some effects. It also makes it look less choppy and more like real lighting. It also hides any modeling problems such as the trees looking wayyy too blocky. For example the two images below where I just added some simple lighting effects to make it look like there’s police lights on.
Screenshot 2023-11-18 143606
Screenshot 2023-11-18 143743

You can also add a whole lot more effects like text, camera raw filters, and just a whole lot more in the background that would look a lot better if you use the first image.

2 Likes