Would players click on this icon, and if not, how could I improve it?

[hellofriend3012]

Here’s the icon that I made:

Here’s the icon that I based my icon off of:

Which of the two would you click, and could you tell me what I could improve on with mine?

[SavAlt17 (sav_YT)]

1st one looks like pure roblox studio with barely any rig editiing and photo editing. so nr 2

[Imdjdjdjdj]

I would click on the second icon if i had to choose between them. You should first try to make it original because they both have a bacon hair and maybe you should add players in the circle. The bacon has no stepping he is just leaning forward also try to fix that

[2112Jay]

Maybe add some light effects to that.

[hellofriend3012]

Does this one look better?

[Imdjdjdjdj]

yeah I think it looks better than the old one