Recently some advice in development support has contained things from bad practices, to stuff that downright break Roblox’s rules.
In my opinion, we should have some sort of a downvote tool integrated for the support categories. This has been discussed in Discourse Meta but refused by the Discourse team because it’s a discussion software, not a Q&A or fact-based system.
This doesn’t work when it comes to development support where some advise may be harmful, and replies about why that’s harmful could be off-topic, or drowned out in a sea of replies.
In fact, systems like this were proposed by members around the time of the Discourse-DevForum’s inception.
To quote Jeff Atwood:
systems of fact, data, and science can benefit from downvotes, because statements can be scientifically proven to a reasonable degree.
You can see here that a lot of people think the development support categories need improvement (just search support
in the topic). I believe that adding a system of accountability to people’s advise that is entirely community-based would be cool.
How would this be possible with Discourse not supporting it?
Plugins! Custom plugins are used a lot on the DevForum. You know that New Topic-automatic-to-post-approval button? That’s a plugin.
This can already be kinda done with this plugin. It even lets you disable categories from it
IRL example
scriptinghelpers.org by @evaera has a reputation system similar to StackOverflow and it works quite well, this is a system built for support- not discussion, and it works. I still see many DevForum members (who have access to dev support) opting to ask their question on StackOverflow, ScriptingHelpers, Discord, etc. because Discourse was not designed for something like this.
What about flags?
Flags are cool. But giving bad advise (e.g. this example shown by @howmanysmaII, which inspired this suggestion) are not against the forum rules.
Would you be in favor of a feature like this?
- Yes
- No
0 voters
If not, why? or What concerns would you have about this?
- It’d be abused (make it members only)
- It’d be abused (don’t add it)
- It makes no sense for Development Support
- I just don’t like it
- Other
0 voters
[center] thanks for reading[/center]