Roblox is supporting COPPA 2 or 2.0 which if passed will include terrible restrictions. Roblox is not even realizing that it will kill their platform literally and that they should not be supporting it. COPPA (Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act) is an act made in 1998 but went into effect in 2000 where companies and websites cannot collect data from people 12 and younger. And yes this is the reason why almost every website you see or smth is 13+. And COPPA ruined Youtube because now either you select whether your channel is for kids or not or you can decide between those two options on every video of your channel.
Kreekcraft summarizes this really well.
COPPA 2.0 aims at basically removing recommendation for young people. Unfortunately, worst part is that the act is aiming at people 16 and younger! Yes you read it right, people who are 16 or younger have more restrictions applied on them basically. I know there is more details on what the restrictions are that are in Kreek’s video and I don’t feel like mentioning more of it. Unfortunately, Roblox is also supporting COPPA 2.0 which will most likely kill their platform if it goes into effect.
So what is your opinion on this situation? One more thing, Kreekcraft is saying that he will go to the white house or Congress building in Washington DC and defend us soon.
Update: I am aware that Kreekcraft had some inaccuracies with the situation according to one of the people who replied pointing out that and linking the video in the reply of Kreekcraft analyzing the document made by @Trelakor.
It wasn’t passed in the House in the 118th Congress. The bill is dead and been for months now. This information came from my Senator in Virginia, Tim Kaine, when I reached out to him about this.
Congress will try future measures though. Stay informed by going to the government websites and if you’re in the United States, know who your Representative and Senators are. Reach out to them. If they don’t listen to their constituents, vote them out.
I guess less informed decisions for Roblox. Recommendation algorithms and data collection in general. There might be specific things Roblox wouldn’t want people to do unless there’s that data collection involved.
Not that it’s 100% like this, or would be, but think of everything people under 13 can’t do on Roblox. I assume that’d extend to those under 16, if that bill passed overall. This is a hypothetical of course.
I’d argue if the act did pass, it’d set a growing precedent of government control in the internet rather than the power being the parent’s.
Also, there is 0.0000000001% that Coppa 2.0 could get approved cuz it didn’t go through since whatever dated back.
Chances are low but not always zero.
There’s a lot of fearmongering regarding COPPA 2.0, now that I’ve actually read the bill - I am pretty certain that Roblox’s support of COPPA 2.0 is a strategic business decision, these are probably the 4 main reasons why:
1: Roblox wouldn’t really be affected by COPPA 2.0’s restrictions on PII due to the fact that COPPA 2.0 doesn’t actually ban companies from collecting PII like some people tend to think.
2: The specific restrictions on targeted advertising that COPPA 2.0 makes are not relevant to Roblox.
3: COPPA 2.0 does make it harder for newer companies to compete, since they probably would want to use targeted ads on YouTube for instance in order to reach a younger audience, with this, that wouldn’t be possible anymore. Additionally, the upfront infrastructure required would be much more expensive for a hypothetical competitor.
4: It looks good to the broader media, I don’t think I need to explain why Roblox finds that very advantageous.
I’m not a lawyer, or a super strong business man or anything like that, but when you see huge support of a proposed bill/new law from a company like we’re seeing with Roblox and COPPA 2.0, that company is almost certainly seeing either dollar signs for themselves, or a red stock number for others.
Bruh how does that cause you to think that those certain users will not able to play or smth? Once you get the context of the situation, the “it will ruin the platform” is gonna be like not what you thought about in the beginning.
Sorry that I fell for some inaccuracies involving Kreek’s video. I know sometimes the situation is a bit exaggerated to basically create more drama. I wasn’t aware of the inaccuracies though. Thank you for pointing it out and showing another video of his talking about it.
It will be like when the original COPPA was actually going to be enforced on youtube in 2020. A big controversy followed by the change really just being a tickbox since the platform is literally unable to moderate who is under 16 and who is 16 or above.
I will not be restrcited. And since the CEO supports this law, no, I dont think 13, 14, 15 yr olds should have their chat, game choose, or anything else restricted. I AM NOT GOING TO BE RESTRICTED BY THIS. NO, this law is by far the worst law i’ve ever seen in the US. i am NOT going to have to watch cocomelon, I AM NOT A BABY!!
This is why i hate society in the USA. They just keep messing stuff UP, congress dont understand the gist of sm and gaming platforms, i hate this LAW.
I’VE BEEN A DEVELOPER FOR SO LONG, GUESS HOW HAPPY I WAS WHEN ROBLOX MESSAGED ME SAYING I WAS NO LONGER NEEDED TO BE UNDER PARANTEL CONTROL. NOW THAT POWER IS JUST GONNA BE TAKEN AWAY BY THE WINEY WINEY CONGRESS AND THEIR LITTLE DUM COPPA 2.0, NO, I WILL NOT. I will not be restrcited, No No NO, i have a life to live of game devlopment and stuff, I WILL NOT BE RESTRICTED. This cant be happening…
And I’ve probably fell to kreeks fermongering… but still, if i have my chat and game choosing restricted, i will rebel.
I hate my existance. You know, i have a life to live, and this law takes away half of my life. I cant take the pain and distrot i feel when i heard about this law, i want to stop the pain, but i cant. I am loosing my mind slowly and slowly. I love making games and hanging out with my freinds playing with them in my games, but if my chat and other good things are restricted, its over, its gonna get worse for me, i will slip into a deep depression, my grades will drop, and i will get worse and worse, there is a point about that. They have to reject this law, or else i will may loose my life or half of it soon… im sorry guys. It cant be over, but it may end soon… no…
The 16-year-olds are gonna be affected too. I don’t get why the age is varying so much when it just 16 and under that have to deal with this. The topic here was dead for some time, thank you for reviving it though bro.
ima be depressed for like five years if this passes and I have enough to worry about with final exams coming up. it will affect a lot of people in a negative way I AM SICK AND TIRED OF THE UNDER 13S BEING TREATED LIKE BABIES. AND NOW THE 16,15,14, AND 13 YR OLDS ARE BEING TREATED LIKE THIS??
like, come on I finally got freedom from the restrictions in FEBUARY AND THEN IM JUST GONNA GET EM PUT BACK ON?!
Half the people on this thread are highlighting why this law is actually useful. People’s almost parasocial obsession with this platform is worrying.
The facts are it won’t stop under 16s from chatting, it just means they will have safe chat.
It won’t stop under 16s from playing games, but it will stop Roblox and other platforms from collecting data so they can recommend you addicting games.
It will also hand parents the powers to limit what their children are playing.
In short, this bill will improve Roblox not kill it.
I AM SICK AND TIRED OF THE UNDER 13S BEING TREATED LIKE BABIES. AND NOW THE 16,15,14, AND 13 YR OLDS ARE BEING TREATED LIKE THIS??