Feedback on my Game Icon

Hey everyone !
A few months ago, I made a icon for my game: Feedback on my Game Icon
Yeah… That sounds bad.

I decided this time to make it in Canva because it’s much easier:

What do you think ?
Does it make you want to play my game?

The screenshots really come from my game
However I used free models for building…

3 Likes

It looks somewhat chaotic, but in an interesting way. I’d probably fill in that part where the background cuts out, so it doesn’t look like you’re looking inside a block.
image

1 Like

Thanks you for your feedback !
Yeah maybe it’s a little weird in the borders between the images
I basically don’t wanted to make any separation
It’s somewhat “clean” like that

The images and shapes don’t fit. You probably should do more of an organized collage of photos.

1 Like

I agree with Roblozinko. Icons are relatively small on the screen so you don’t want them to be too busy; rather something easy to digest but still pops out as it will only be a split second the player sees it as they’re scrolling through. Try removing the smaller images, keep the text as it is and try to find a full version of the top screenshot and use it as a background.

1 Like

Thanks for your comment !
I think you’re right
Images are pretty small

I recommend using PhotoPea (yes I know that you already used it, but use a tutorial for an icon) if you want a cartoony icon, but the only thing not good about PhotoPea is that it’s a bit complex.

This was my second logo using PhotoPea:

Woahhhh

A LOT is happening in the icon and it leaves me a bit confused about whats happening.

I have a star , wings , person being hit by something? , desk with lampost etc

Would simplify a bit.