Your argument is completely without facts. Guilded has no where near the amount of usage of discord, nor the ability to even match discord and would be chosen over it. You see how roblox is now releasing video calling and actually endorsing you know what on roblox? Do your own research and stop being a fanboy, no pun intended.
1 Like
people make this terrible argument all the time, just because there have been no seen cases of it doesnāt mean there isnāt. Guilded is literally just a worse clone of Discord, and it would be nice if the engineers actually knew that; especially considering people like zeux themselves have Discord accounts.
4 Likes
Yeah I know that Guilded is safer because its first party but I donāt personally know a single person that uses Guilded which automatically makes it unattractive to me. And I also donāt think this will ever change, discord is alot better overall and the popularity among non gamers is much bigger too thats why Gilded will never become superior to discord
Because Roblox moved all of their private program servers to Guilded >.<
I know very, very few top developers who actually use Guilded for anything but communicating with Roblox staff.
1 Like
Not a terrible update, yet I donāt think anyone cares much about Guilded, yet possibly for the people who do care, good on you. I would love to see a Discord integration in the future, I know they are not partnered but I think something other than the button link you can put in a group or a game would be a helpful addition since there are way more people active on Discord than Guilded.
1 Like
This update is honestly whatever imo. Not very enticing if I do say so myself.
Guilded is lowkey just ohio discord.
1 Like
Heās literality just addressing concerns that have already been made plenty of times by the community itself and thereās a lot of proof out there already that show these are actual problems.
You canāt really provide a fair judgement between the two platforms since Guilded isnāt really pushed or advertised much by Roblox at the moment, so itās quite obvious why itās not popular yet.
Now I can understand people being frustrated over all the useless updates that are being published like animated emotes since I dislike them aswell, but thatās not an excuse to be passive aggressive towards another poster that hasnāt done anything wrong.
And the Guilded stuff is clearly being done in response to all the child safety concerns that have been going around, so thereās no reason to get annoyed about that either.
( If they start forcing everyone to use it on the other hand, thatās a different story.)
1 Like
I donāt believe itās in response for that at all. Guilded will have the same issue, even more so because roblox is actively making it a possibility due to the video call in the works and the fact they are wanting to push this more towards edating, which is not a good idea at all for metrics.
2 Likes
DevRel has invite-only programs to Guilded as mentioned by a few above like @Timelens and @grilme99 .
These serve as a communication access between all program members giving a likeminded-safespace for top developers and ease of communication to staff.
Most of the āproofā you ask is strictly under NDA.
Guilded does have the potential to compete with discord, itās just a race against a few odds.
Yes, right now only the presence of developers has been notable, communities havenāt decided a new move there yet.
At the same time, I do see a few new communities being set up so things would be interesting to watch, maybe in a year or two.
All I would say is that just because you love discord, you donāt have to hate Guilded. Appreciate both and maybe even try the latter to see how things work for you!
2 Likes
Itās like comparing the crime rates in New York City to a small rural town in Wyoming.
Thereās a lot more crimes in New York City than the Wyoming Town because thereās far more people in New York City compared to the Wyoming Town.
1 Like
better discord is against discord TOS. so roblox supporting it would be basically like going to war with discord
guided communities were always linkable so i have no idea what the hell you are talking about right now. In fact nothing is changing this is only an adā¦ Which theyāre not even ashamed of admitting to lol
Well thank for ACTUALLY providing some meaningful information! The NDA explains it.
well thatās why Roblox is adding this feature, to send users to Guilded, since Roblox does own Guilded and its kinda dead.
Just cause you donāt use guilded doesnāt mean its useless.
Guilded is sorta great. it has many useful features compared to Discord itself, however what i dislike about guilded is the UI. its too complicated and to this day i donāt know what most buttons even do.
You can also use Guilded to bypass the Discord API, since Discord doesnāt allow Roblox API ran on their webhooks.
You can also use Guilded to Work with ur developers incase you donāt want to use trello.
3 Likes
Please actually learn to take in facts and do research. āoh but its popularā is not a valid argument at all brudda. Discord is full of pedophiles.
2 Likes
Take in facts, stop assuming. āterrible argumentā ājust a cloneā is all because you dont know how to accept new things
1 Like
Learn how to accept new things mate. Thats like saying grass is a copy of dirt because it has similiar features
1 Like
Yeah sorry Iām already using Discord, but itās cool that youāre trying to help make communities for us!
1 Like
Its funny youre saying that considering the fact you yourself didnt even do research and act like a fanboy.
Like my man, have you been living under a rock or something?
I mean sure, Guilded isnt perfect, however if you think about Roblox adding Discord community integration more, you start to realize the cracks.
The main big thing isā¦ child predatorsā¦ Discord is basically the easy gate way for child predators to get in contact with minors. And before you say āhow about you do research and stop being a fanboyā.
Discord would be a big risk for Roblox to add something like an integration, considering theyre bad at handling with people who are child predators because theyre technically are doing it off platform.
Guilded may not be popular and not isnt user friendly, but i would like Roblox to promote their own platform they bought instead of promoting an platform that would pontentially give more child predators access to minors.
And this child predator thing isnt just related with Discord Roblox servers, its beyond Roblox itself, Discord is legit horrible platform relating to safety of minors. And there are other problems Discord has that i legit cant even mention here without getting in trouble.
Plus I myself had mix feelings with using Discord, when i was 15 some guy on a Roblox Discord server i was on, used alt accounts to post gore pictures, videos and gifs on my dms. It was horrible.
Basically long story short, you have to think a lot before adding something like an Discord community intergration, and im glad they didnt do that.
Its okay if you dont like this update, just know that you arent being forced to use Guilded.
2 Likes