Help deciding which monster looks Scarier for a forest horror game

So I’m working on a realistic Bigfoot hunting game, but I feel like the Bigfoot monster is overused. I found 2 alternatives that suited the look I want. I wasn’t sure which one looked better so I’m asking yall. Please vote for the one yall think is better based upon this criteria.

Forest monster.
Scary.
Extremely scary at night.
Would be more scared of.

I personally think 1. I think it is super similar to Bigfoot, which was what I as originally going for.

  • 1
  • 2

0 voters

Definitely the first one. It gives big foot vibes, which is really good.


This is Bambi, a mutant deer from the horror movie “Bambi: The Reckoning.” At night it’s eyes sort of turn white and it gives this really creepy vibe, which would be perfect for that monster. Especially at night.

Sorry for the pause and skip symbols. I couldn’t get rid of them lol.

1 Like

I was thinking of this too! Thanks for the reply!

1 Like

1 looks like a furry 2 is much cooler in my opinion

2 Likes

1 is a werewolf and is as tired as bigfoot

2 is a humanoid like bigfoot, but has a woodsy vibe

I would do something like 2 with the face of 1

1 Like

I’ll try this idea. Very unique.

You could always add both of them. During a blood moon or something Number #2 spawns alongside and helps Number #1, making it harder.

1 Like

Good idea, but I don’t really want that to happen in my game.

Alright. How about a separate game mode? I know this is dum to ask since I know the game is in development. But both of these creatures look so good. It would be cool to have both of them take place in your game. In a different gamemode or area.

1 Like

I’ve been talking to one of my friends who has been helping in the game a little, and I brought up this exact same idea. Although like you said, the game is in development right now it would be too much to add 2 monsters at the beginning, but very good idea. May add it later as an update though!

1 Like

Are y’all familiar with the Bigfoot game on steam? That’s how I want the game to turn out. Here is a link to my devlogs if yall wanna check out the progress.

Here is the first devlog

Here is the second devlog

2 Likes

2 is more unique looking, 1 looks a wee bit stereotypical.

2 Likes

You could just do a Monster Hunter game.

There are a lot of mythical creatures. Each one might have a different setting and require different tactics for hunting and capturing/killing.

It might be more fun than hunting Bigfoot over and over.

2 Likes

Might do that in the future! I think I’ll stick with the current idea on this one though.