Is there a way to make an Experience be classified as a Voice Chat experience? Or are all games that have Voice Chat Enabled classified as a Voice Chat experience?
8 Likes
why should players verify their phone number in such an inconvenient place as in-game, instead of in a secure place?
not to mention, what about mobile players? verifying on your phone while playing on it must be one of the most uncomfortable things ever.
also, as some people stated, what about those developers who track inputs when players input their phone numbers? i would rather be putting such personal information in a place where i can deem it safe instead of a place in which a rando mightâve placed a tracker down to mess with me
19 Likes
scam games as they kick you out the second you receive voice chat (theyve been collecting every input you do)
8 Likes
How will this work with UserInputService?
It would be very bad if game owners can detect the keystrokes when a user is entering their number.
I assume you already figured that out, but just making sure.
9 Likes
What about the measures of security? People will just mimic the UI into possibly logging Numbers no? I might be heavily mistaken.
8 Likes
Canât developers just use UserInputService to listen for input and store private phone numbers? This doesnât seem too safe.
6 Likes
No, remember the incident where CoreGui was manipulated to make fake purchases or execute unwanted purchases under a blurry screen?
Yes that is possible, new chat ui is stored under coregui and its possible.
6 Likes
This will MAYBE be used for phishing. Roblox probably will put it inside CoreGui, but then exploiters/some kind of engineering will use it to know the userâs phone number. Meh update 
10 Likes
This read to me as; âYou could not previously register a phone number with your roblox account from inside a game. You now can!!! (If you donât want to use the settings)â not âYou must now register your phone number in order to play roblox!!!â
Iâm not sure what data you guys are working off as well but this just strikes me as wholly unnecessary.
5 Likes
Do you have any reading comprehension skills?
5 Likes
I still donât really get whatâs the point of this update? Convenience, sure, but this update is opening a whole can of worms with malicious developers potentially exploiting this update to get mobile numbers of Players.
5 Likes
The lack of critical thinking in the replies are obvious and overflowing.
âthe Account Identity team will be running an experiment in which users can verify their phone number in a Voice Chat experience instead of having to leave the experience to verify their phone number in settings.â
This statement implies that the Account ID team are the ones who will go through the verification on most likely popular places with VC enabled, as some sort of QA.
Itâs not something that you who probably donât use VA or donât have a community should be worried about.
The post is also vague, so there might be a lot going on behind the scenes that we are not aware of.
Key note of the entire post: experiment
The whole point of this is to collect useful data to prevent exactly what is being so negatively talked about in the replies.
4 Likes
Exactly this ^^^ huge security flaw
2 Likes
Why are we using phone numbers for voice chat anyways? Having a phone number attached to your account is a huge security concern.
8 Likes
by pushing phone verification, you compromise the security of your users. SMS is not secure, all it takes is a child with malicious intent making a phone call to the carrier to steal the users phone number. you seriously need to rethink this
3 Likes
this seems like a terrible idea, couldnât a developer easily grab someones phone number?
3 Likes
This is convenience over safety/security.
A malicious developer could easily make a UI very similar to ROBLOX Official UI, ask the user for their phone number in (empty) promise for Voice Chat, but instead send it to a database to do something stupid like sell their number. Even worse, that number could be used for blackmail, threats, and other malicious activity.
While yes, at some point the experience would receive action and get taken down that would most likely be too late, whatâs done is done, and whatâs really stopping the developer from doing it again?
If you need to enter important details for a service ROBLOX provides, then you should do it on the official ROBLOX website where thereâs no risk of such a thing happening.
4 Likes
I mean come onâŠ
I just did this in only 17 minutes.
Obviously Iâm not gonna use it, I may have the moral compass of a cuckoo clock but Iâm not sick in the head.
8 Likes
Oh man, I didnât even think about that. Thatâs way worse⊠WAY worse.
⊠should I be concerned?
1 Like
I think this is a bad idea. Why canât you show a pop-up after clicking on the âPlayâ button?
2 Likes