Particles are drawn above/under decals based on camera angle instead of physical position

[MrHistory]

https://vid.me/eZTD

It appears to depend on whether the camera is pointing above or below the horizon. If below, particles are drawn below the decal. If above, particles are drawn above the decal. From the camera’s perspective, the part that contains the ParticleEmitter is in front of the face with the decal, so particles should always be drawn on top of the decal.

ParticleBugRepro.rbxl (11.5 KB)

[Sharksie]

This is intended. A Decal isn’t a physical thing - it’s a texture on a transparent part. Transparent parts appear in depth order instead of each face occluding each other face the way you would expect. Particles do the same thing. So if the center of your transparent part is closer to the camera than the center of your particle part your decal will appear on top of the particles.

[buildthomas]

Here’s an explanation of what @Sharksie means using a different example:

Rendering fixes (January 2016)

This kills me :\

https://i.gyazo.com/8ab3ac6b774b1cb924da49ee2dd07f7a.gif

There’s a transparent part in the far distance with a decal on it which is overlapping a transparent part in the foreground with a decal on it. Does anyone know any kind of solution?

Rendering fixes (January 2016)

Something like this is happening in your gif:

Due to the angle of the camera, the center of the semi transparent part in the background is closer to the plane on which the camera lies, so it gets sorted before the center of the transparent foliage part.

[MrHistory]

This seems like a problem. From a developer’s and player’s standpoint, a texture in 3d space should behave like anything else in 3d space.

[Sharksie]

Unfortunately the solution to this is per-pixel layering, which is prohibitively expensive. Every game engine that I know of has this same problem.

[NWSpacek]

It seems there has been a change to the depth sort for the worse. I can’t explain it exactly, but it seems like it had better performance.