Are you able to make the names not so big and fit more on the screen?
4 Likes
Is there any way to make the PlayerList smaller by any chance? [By smaller, I mean the gaps between each player on the PlayerList.]
other name is hidden because of privacy.
13 Likes
The old design should really come back. I just donāt see how the new one is any better than the old one. If anything it just makes things worse.
8 Likes
I see the update has been pushed! It looks good but will we ever see updates to the other UI like the backpack?
Currently the backpack looks awful. It looks compared to the rest of the UI, I would much prefer for it look rounder and a little more complex than how it looks currently, like the new players list.
4 Likes
Iām pretty sure they stated that an entirely new UI will be coming in the future.
1 Like
The player list density is not great on 1366x768 laptop screens.
I can only see about 8 players at a time, which is worse compared to the old list. Previously I was able to see 14, nearly double.
Plus the player menu looks out of place because of its large size.
I think I see your intention: Making it consistent with the website design. Unfortunately, the player list is more of a gameplay element, and padding the names like this damages its usability especially on 1366x768 screens, which is still the most common size for desktop screens.
I think itās more important to be designed around gameplay instead of around what the web designers did with the other Roblox UIs.
Please reduce the padding!
13 Likes
Going off of personal opinion here, I prefer the older player list over this new player list. The reason being the old design was more compact and convenient. The names were closer together. With this new design, the user will have to scroll through the player names instead of seeing a complete list (around 20-25) of usernames. Reading through othersā opinions, I see I am not alone on this. If this new list was brought down to the size of the original list, I feel as if this feature would receive less harsh, and even more positive feedback than it has.
-DyoxDev
16 Likes
Itās pretty great and modern. My only complain is that the playerās name cuts off when itās long, Other than that this is a great update.
1 Like
Would you say making the names smaller and closer together would be a better option than having the names larger and cut off?
The text is too large for my liking, ya.
4 Likes
I donāt know how much I like this new player list. It takes up around 25%-30% of the entire right side of my screen horizontally and 50% vertically.
10 Likes
I donāt know if someone has suggested this yet but I would like it to return that you can see your own stats at the top of the player list, so you dont have to search yourself in the player list.
6 Likes
I feel that my only complain with the player list is how big it is, and the names specifically. In games I play often, watching the entire player list is very helpful, but with the currently player list I can fit 1/2 to 1/3 of the names it could before, leading to almost 5 seconds of scrolling to see the entire thing, which is a big downgrade in my eyes.
3 Likes
I think this is a step in the right direction, but it went too far and needs to be dialed down. I still would prefer the old player list, for the reason it was convenient. The current one is far too spaced out, and large. Having to scroll for just 10 players is quite annoying, whereas the old one could have 15-20 (for me at least). I think if the spacing was brought down to the old player lists spacing, or within a few pixels would make it both convenient whist retaining most of the redesign.
If Iām being brutally honest, it feels like someone made a UI for mobile and shipped it to all platforms with no changes, since it is the only platform I feel like this new UI might be decent on.
5 Likes
My opinion is pretty much the same as everybody elseās. Itās too intrusive, each cell is too high (in y) and the colour of it just isnāt appealing. The menuās that pop up when clicking a player are massive but at least there arenāt any obvious scaling issues. The old one was simple which was great, this one is too detailed in my opinion and I donāt exactly know what the issue was to change the old one.
4 Likes
I think it occupies too much space compared to the older version and contains less information without scrolling. I believe this fits mobile players more than PC players
3 Likes
If the team name is long, it overlaps with the other thingy, for example if you have a rank leaderboard.
I still think that the leader board is pretty large when there is lots of stats to show. As shown in @wravagerās post, it takes up almost a quarter of the right side of the screen and almost half of the bottom right half of the screen that could be used for game features.
Otherwise, I think that this player list is really aesthetically pleasing, and looks really clean and modern. It also has lots of improvements from the older version of this new player list. Only touch it could use is size, and maybe some of the other guis could be upgraded too to fit this clean, modern design too.
One last complaint I have is the size of the menu that opens when you click a players name, still feel like it takes up too much space as well.
Nice work on this update, really excited to see what it turns out to be in the future!
3 Likes
Overall, I like the new playerlist!
I just have one complaint.
Compared to the old playerlist, this seems extremely large. It may annoy some players because it takes up space to click. If it was resized, it would be more comfortable to use. I agree with Virtuez, I think this update is more for mobile players.
11 Likes
Old one was MUCH better, please change it back. This one is too cartoony and will wreck the experience for more realistic games.
16 Likes