I have been consulting on choosing what game idea should I do I already plan a game for support for this game.
But I have been tied up on which ideas to choose
I’ll explain each idea and then please take a poll down below Space Invaders
the idea is that you go into caves (in 2d) and try to find treasure while using guns to fight aliens Top-down Adventure game
I don’t know the theme or story just yet however I want it to have a survival aspect as like Breath of the wild The Awakened
This game idea is similar to a preexisting game the apocalypses however the key takeaways are it’s in the third person and you can build forts Private Torcher Chamber(or PTC for short)
This idea is where you run a torching business for all mighty goblin king it’s like a tycoon but top-down and every day a new event happens. it will be pixelated A Fnaf style game
I am a huge fan of these types of games I want to add a twist where the animatronic’s move on camera instead of disappearing and reappearing out and you need to find them and zap them.
If you are really stuck, then you could always do an Improvisation Build; take all these aspects, and mesh them together, it might turn out a fun project!
In my opinion you shouldn’t really care about which game idea is superior. You should ideally ask yourself: Is it a game I would want to play? Is it a game which I can execute well? If the answers to both questions are yes, then you should proceed with it.
If you do not create a game which you yourself would not want to play, what you will found out really quickly is that you will likely lose motivation while developing it. Even if you do get to the stage of release, you may find it continually hard to form ideas for new updates.
You can have the most original and amazing game idea that no-one has done before but it does not necessarily mean that it would be fun and enjoyable. If you do not have the proper knowledge or skills to create it well, then it could be buggy and even unplayable leading to a poor audience response.
Those are all great points however the reason i’m having this poll is because I find all these ideas great and the ability to update them also i want to find a game which people will play not a game people will just find cool
However you are right i should try to find the abilities to make games so they are great.
Honestly all those ideas have great potential, although the Private Torcher Chamber (PTC) is the best in my opinion. Your description isn’t really much, but I would imagine it’s an interactive tycoon like Restaurant or Retail tycoon (correct me if I’m wrong). If so, you should be able to get a decent player base if it’s well made, even if it isn’t a unique masterpiece.