I searched for each of the item IDs listed on the ban screen in the original post on the Rolimon’s website, and none of them were ‘holdable items.’ However, if there’s any clarification on this matter, I’d be happy to hear it. From the title alone, there already seems to be an inconsistency.
Another point I need to address is that these items actually violate the rules and should never have been allowed in the first place. Just because they’ve been available on the platform for an extended period doesn’t automatically mean they followed the rules or that the rules have changed recently.
These “clothing” items that make body parts invisible—essentially layered clothing exploits—do indeed abuse the platform’s systems. They allow users to completely remove their avatar and replace it with, for example, an animal figure or a random object of their choice. This exploit has been used by all the creators who were recently banned, and the ban reason was absolutely valid. Next time, when uploading layered clothing, creators should make items that genuinely add layers to the avatar (as the name ‘layered clothing’ implies) rather than exploiting the system to manipulate the avatar itself.
I don’t understand why people are trying to portray these items as innocent in the replies to this post. Please take a more objective approach. And no, items that partially or completely make body parts invisible (in other words, exploitative items) have never been allowed. I genuinely struggle to comprehend some of the replies in this post.
That said, there’s one area where I disagree with Roblox moderation: the handling of bans under the ‘Misusing Roblox Systems’ reason. This ban reason is treated differently from others and can lead directly to account deletion. Normally, with other ban reasons, once a ban is issued (e.g., a 1-day ban), any item that caused the ban and is later deleted does not escalate the ban or result in longer durations or account deletion. However, for the ‘Misusing Systems’ reason, moderation stacks up regardless of the circumstances. Your account can be deleted within seconds based on the number of deleted items, which is like a nightmare. I believe this is the main issue that needs to be addressed.
Otherwise, the items created by these banned creators are still rule-breaking and have always been against the rules. This wasn’t due to a ‘recent’ rule change; the same rule has been in place for years. The issue is simply that this specific ban reason operates differently, leading to sudden mass account deletions. If the moderation policies applied to other ban reasons were also applied here, this issue would be resolved.
Of course, if a creator repeatedly violates the rules, they’ll eventually have to say goodbye to their account. However, having it happen at lightning speed and all at once is an undesirable outcome.
