Okay, it sounds like you’ve come to the conclusion I’m not a hypocrite. Can we delete our half-a-page of thread derailing now? I’ll be more than happy to discuss re-using generic audio assets after that. If we don’t do that, the thread will probably get locked, and that obviously isn’t something I want.
You are a hypocrite, because assuming the quote you combated was taken in its entirety and its context, you basically said
“Using another upload of a sound effect of a thud is the equivalent in severity to pirating; illegally stealing or replicating content. However, actually doing that illegal activity in question (WITH COMPANIES THAT EXPRESSED A GREAT DEAL OF CONCERN OVER COPYRIGHT AND MADE MANY DISPUTES ON A VARIETY OF OTHER MEDIA/ ACTUAL ART PLATFORMS) is inconsequential, even if it’s being used for actual REAL profit.”
And I even tried to give examples that even in the context of a self contained, “respect” based community, content and assets being stolen doesn’t actually have an effect.
And I even pointed out that what you described as piracy, owning content, and stealing stands on a false basis, that is that you “own” the sounds you upload, where in reality you only actually paid for moderation, and those sounds are in reality owned by Roblox.
For the love of god, Aurarus. I give you chance to un-derail the thread and you insist on making it worse. You’re making claims that have already been addressed, and are leading this in circles.
[quote]
And I even pointed out that what you described as piracy, owning content, and stealing stands on a false basis, that is that you “own” the sounds you upload, where in reality you only actually paid for moderation, and those sounds are in reality owned by Roblox. [/quote]
Not once did I ever claim we owned rights to audio because we paid to upload it. Stop putting words in my mouth to feed your gluttony for proving people wrong. And no, those sounds are not owned by ROBLOX – they’re owned by their respective IP holders. Uploading sounds just gives ROBLOX the right to host it on their site.
I’m not going to babysit you. I’ve deleted all of my previous posts because I am not going to stand for feeding this derailment. This will also be my last post in response to you. I suggest you delete your previous posts if you have any sense of respect for Polyhex and his thread.
[quote]
1 Like