AND to top that off the person made a lot of USD worth of Robux from that item.
1 Like
Why are there so many star creators in the UGC program? Most of them donât even know how to model, they let other people do it for them. I think this is pretty unfair for the people who are actually talented and are still not in the program.
18 Likes
Do you need premium to make ugc?
3 Likes
about a year later, we now see why ugc has been a terrible idea, the catalog is being spammed with low-effort copy-paste hats that just make idiotic amounts of robux for virtually no effort, most of those people are not even the original creators of the meshes they uploadâŚ
2 Likes
You canât really blame them for making low effort items when people buy them. The question isnât how are they making so much money. Itâs why are people buying it.
Also Iâve stated this before. Roblox doesnt own copyright over tophats. @Revocial
2 Likes
Actually ive seen a lot of original content. Like hair and tophats.
4 Likes
I disagree, I feel that there are a lot of original items on the catalog, and since the UGC creators have better connection with the community, we see hats we like and wanât more.
3 Likes
Star creators follow different rules and are added seperately. Star creators being added doesnât take up âslotsâ for potential actual modelers.
Itâs a blatant lie and extremely unfair to say this. Thereâs cases where people reuse unoriginal meshes or even singular cases where the creators donât have rights to the meshes, but the vast majority of uploads are original creations made for the purpose of getting uploaded to the UGC accessory catalog.
3 Likes
You gotta post your things to be seen I think?
But either way I think they are opening up actual applications in a couple months.
3 Likes
If the market wants it, whatâs the issue with creating it?
7 Likes
Because a select few people are making a huge profit off of 3d modeling that requires little to no effort, while actual talented creators arenât getting this opportunity.
2 Likes
Except to some, UGC is a job. Thereâs literally nothing wrong with targeting that area of the market and making those hats. Itâs the players who want it after all.
And you act like these types of hats are the only assets being created. Look at IDontHaveAUse, he put out the cube and such but has an incredible lineup of work such as this.
4 Likes
They are able to make a huge profit since they hold a monopoly on the market.
Remember, UGC program members have a say in who gets into the program via the nominations process.
2 Likes
Huh, does this mean that the application process is not happening?
âwhen or IFâ implies that it isnât.
2 Likes
Thereâs the possibility they werenât 100% certain it was happening, so they just said âifâ in order to prevent people from quoting them in the future.
1 Like
That isnât a good sign.
If they arenât doing an application, does that mean going back to the nomination process 
1 Like
if you dont like it, dont buy it? your argument is like trying to argue a developer shouldnt be allowed to make a âgold nametagâ pass 5,000 robux.
4 Likes
The difference being that making a 5000 rbx gold nametag pass is not restricted to âinfluencersâ and a seemingly arbitrary select few other people. There are plenty of actual modelers here who would love to add things that have some actual thought and quality put into them instead of âReused Asset But With a Rainbow Outline #243â or âIronically (but not really that ironic) Low Effort Shapeâ or âOld Model I Had Laying Around But Scaled Up So Itâs Definitely a Costume I Swearâ.
For a lot of modelers, the opportunity to be able to put their 3D cosmetics on the Roblox catalogue is an incredibly exciting and enticing one, so itâs very discouraging to see a huge number of factory made, copy-pasted, low effort absolute garbage filling it up. That, and this program has been out for over a year now with barely any communication or updates.
Weâve had this carrot on a stick dangling above us for quite a while now and thereâs no sign of the situation changing, but a lot of us still hope.
12 Likes
Finally! This is insane! Roblox is becoming the best developing platform if it is not yet
3 Likes