Which Skybox is better (POLL)?

The team is having a conflict over which skybox is better.

Skybox A:


Skybox B:

  • A
  • B

0 voters

EDIT: We ended up choosing a different skybox with clouds; one we could all agree on. This poll helped massively though in finding out what others liked. Thank you.

12 Likes

I personally believe B doesn’t really include any detail and looks very bland.

8 Likes

Every skybox depends the first one:
A.i would say is more realistic and makes the game more realistic and detailed.
B. I would say with this one seems more cartoony style and more calm makes the game more simulator type, but makes the game clear and unique.

2 Likes

Though the game seems to be a low poly type game, I’d suggest using Skybox A, due to the fact it gives a very good and detailed look to the game that Skybox B can’t provide.

3 Likes

the skybox (A) looks more relaxing due to the tone of the sky and gives a perfect combination with the ocean / sea.

2 Likes

The first makes me feel strange, because it looks like a realistic sky, in a blocky and maybe low-poly game, no no.

I choose the second, because looks more basic.

5 Likes

In a cartoon-like game, I personally prefer B since it’s simplistic and fits in with the background.

2 Likes

The simple gradient of skybox B matches perfectly with the games style, the fact that skybox A looks more detailed shouldn’t be a factor in determining which skybox to use. The only downside of skybox B is that there’s no clouds, though it shouldn’t affect the games design as it can be seen as a clear blue sky (common in this type of setting, or pretty much anywhere)

3 Likes

Considering the game appears to be going for a more low poly approach; I would suggest B because it’s simpler so it’ll fit better.

2 Likes

I think B looks at look better for your game. Skybox A is too realistic and doesn’t fit with your games style like B does.

Skybox B is WAY better. It fits your game and Skybox A could be used for something else.

B Looks pretty bland. I can totally agree with @TypicallyShadow.

1 Like

Skybox A looks better, but doesn’t fit the style with too many details, while skybox B blends nearly perfectly.

I don’t know but A makes it feel like you’re in a toy-set in real life, while B is full cartoon

1 Like

B. Because I like clouds makes it more realistic.

1 Like

I prefer B, because A is a bit busy, and B also goes with the aesthetic of the low-poly island better. Both of them are beautiful, though.

2 Likes

B seems like it fits the cartoonish look better, but at the same time looks pretty empty.

I chose A.

1 Like

I broke the tie :shock:

I personally think that A is better, but both of them have their cons.

A is too realistic while B is too bland

But they have their pros, too

A adds more to the scene, and the water reflections look nice, too, but, B more or less fits to your build style

I believe that B looks better because, even though it looks simpler and less detailed, it really matches the scene that you have depicted in this!

If you’re going for a cartoon like scheme then id choose B, but for more realistic type of scheme, I would choose A