I am super glad that this was announced to the community with an option for feedback before going live! That was a disaster last time.
The UI itself is looking a lot better since last time!
Unfortunately, I still don’t love it.
For one - the transparency doesn’t match the default toolbar. The fonts also do not align, however, I assume the other UIs will get an update too, so we’ll have to wait on that I guess.
The scrollbar is big and bulky and impedes on the UI itself. I understand it was to fix the old playerlist’s tiny scrollbar problem, but it does seem a bit forced.
One thing I don’t love is how big the list elements actually are. The player names themselves are vertically huge compared to the old design. The old design was great and compact - you could easily see a large amount of players all at once. This design does limit how much you can see at once. This is sort of like Discord’s Cozy vs. Compact appearance:
Personally I would prefer the playerlist to be more compact, but this is personal preference.
I think that this is a step in the right direction, but I’m not sure if I like it now. I’m very sure that if this does get implemented, it won’t be the worst thing in the world, but it will definitely be unnatural for a little while.