Coming from a person who loves social and competitive games where voice communication is very important, I am not fully on any bandwagon when it comes to this topic. In the right situation, it can really enhance how people play games and communicate. For some games (outside of the platform), they simply wouldn’t work without in-game communication. My first thought would be Counter Blox, whose non-ROBLOX counterpart relies heavily on team-mate coordination and call-outs that can’t be done quick enough by typing.
The idea behind it is very good, actually, if you do look at ROBLOX as a game engine and platform. ROBLOX has obviously taken strides to expand who is playing their game, and by categorizing accounts into ‘13+’ or ‘under 13’, it’s been able to do so somewhat successfully.
As with any platform, making an account that is 13+ to use a service is not foolproof. If we want to compare to a platform like Steam, or even Discord, there is no “verification” and it all boils down to liability and the terms you agree to when signing up. Even 13 year olds don’t belong on many Discord servers, and to be exposed to unfiltered voice and text chats, but that’s just how it is.
It all boils down to making ROBLOX a platform that is welcoming to 13+ people, and that is more difficult than it seems. As of right now, the community, regardless if they’re 13+, sometimes can’t even say large numbers, their own usernames, or even mention social platforms outside of ROBLOX to communicate better on, without being filtered out. The standard for maturity on the platform and the extent at which people can communicate has already been set, and adding voice communication is a big leap.
I think the idea is right, and timing is not. Work on these things that scream “ROBLOX is a platform for children”, and start yelling “ROBLOX is a platform for everyone.” Give older players some more freedom first, and then make the jump to voice communication. I feel like everyone is wondering in their head “how are they gonna filter us in voice chat,” and also believe that the text filtering has gotten a bit too far. In my opinion, work with what we have. Once we finish that, then we start adding.