How would it be determined if the user needs access to the categories or not though? Some developers frequently use Studio but have little to no presence on the Developer forum but still file bug reports
2 Likes
- It IS unfair.
- Why do you think that “top devs” need these categories the most?
Somehow I don’t see many bug reports or feature requests coming from these “top devs”.
I’m not a “top dev” yet I had a few bug reports approved and many more on my to-do list, however I don’t write them due to the inefficiency of Bug-Support.
5 Likes
Yeah same here. I’ve attempted to report quite a few bugs but many just get ignored by Bug Support.
3 Likes
What’s your definition of “top dev” here? Why would you not be a top creator yet?
If you use Studio a lot, you should be in queue to rank up IMO. I meant “top creators” as in the top people in terms of Studio usage. Not based on financial performance or whatever other criteria – please try not to put words in my mouth.
It’s stupid simple: they already have metrics on studio usage time and other feature engagement metrics.
3 Likes
I see. I honestly didn’t know they kept track of that.
I thought you had been referring to top developers in terms of games that they have developed.
1 Like
Just came across someone today who was ranked for having a ‘popular’ game, they joined the forum this year so there is no other reason for them getting regular. The user is actively breaking forum rules (especially in categories only regular can post on) and is refusing to follow the rules even when asked to do so. This proves my point that not every ‘successful’ developer is fit for regular on the DevForum.
9 Likes
Thank you
I agree immensely. At least once a day, you most likely to see a “opinions on this Roblox update” dev discussion post.
Then you have the arguments, because some people don’t respect your opinion or resource. People go out of their way a lot to start silly and unnecessary arguments and almost never get to the point. My respect level for certain developers has gone down for this reason.
Thats the end of my rant, thank you.
3 Likes
Honestly, any report that the moderation team gets, no matter what, they’ll take down the post. I’ve had numerous posts get taken down for no reason, when they were completely legit posts that never should have gotten taken down. Everyone always says the moderation on here is “better” than Roblox’s moderation, but it honestly isn’t.
I highly doubt that’s true; there’s been plenty of times where I’ve flagged a post and the post continues to stay up months later.
Also, “completely legit posts” sounds subjective, do you have any examples of posts you made that were taken down?
3 Likes
A developer said that they were having trouble with their experience loading properly in studio. They said that they were camping. I responded saying you probably shouldn’t develop while camping. That got taken down for “off topic reply”…
Another topic was me talking about the audio update; That got taken down, for no reason. (So I posted another, and that didn’t get taken down.)
I have to agree with moderation here, I’m pretty sure depending on your speeds, you can get perfectly good speeds on 4G.
Either way, talking about people’s decisions on where to develop isn’t really of relevance.
1 Like
I have to totally agree. For WEEKS I’ve been plagued by a bug that is stopping me from properly using Studio. I would’ve submitted a bug report instantly, but no, instead I have to be regular to post one. Like why? Everyone should be allowed to post a bug report, not just regulars.
Roblox Developer Relations, PLEASE change this and allow members to make bug reports.
1 Like
You can message @Bug-Support team about the bug, you have to do this if you wanna post a bug report as a member.
5 Likes
You actually can do that, but it’s just way slower. By messaging @Bug-Support, you can submit bugs. I totally agree though, it is a bit unfair because you don’t usually get regular very quickly on the forum… I rarely ever see anyone get chosen to be a regular but it does specifically say, ‘Level up to Regular is currently available by invitation only.’ It’s a bit unfair.
Sorry for the wall of text. I really don’t know how to split my text up into smaller parts…
(This is probably one of the longest replies i’ve ever done lol)
1 Like
Hey all, thanks for contributing to this thread.
This thread covers many separate issues and it is therefore hard to address. The following things appear to be covered:
- There were differences between forum trust levels and no clear way to “rank up”.
- We have been selective in the people that were added to the higher trust level due to scale limitations.
- The overall perceived quality of forum content, specifically in #development-discussion.
- Perceived clarity and consistency around moderation.
For 1/2, we are actively addressing these issues. There is actually no difference anymore between forum trust levels in terms of their permissions. We have moved the remaining differences (the crucial ones being bug report access and feature request access) into separate groups, and the permission is now managed via these groups. You can expect the trust level designation to diminish over time and we may have some separate announcements about this in the future.
For #bug-reports access, you are now able to request to join to get the permission due to the Big Bug Reporting Update.
Everybody here in the current topic that made a post or Liked one of the posts (as of Mar 19) has had their join request to AllowBugReports accepted if they submitted one.
For the #feature-requests side of the matter, I am consolidating the threads about this issue into one thread, namely this one: All forum users should have a path forward to be able to post in feature requests - #154 by Hooksmith.
Please check out the update I posted there for further information.
The issues 3/4 are very different from 1/2 and should be posted as problems in their own threads. If they are still relevant to you, you are welcome to recreate topics for those issues with additional details.
Issues 1/2 are largely resolved. For the feature request side, please continue the discussion in the thread linked above.
Closing this out now due to the reasons above. Thanks again for posting this and for your patience as we work through these issues.
3 Likes