No email received from asset being falsely taken down

[Arylist]

I usually receive false DMCA claims very often, but today this is a new case. The private asset was taken down automatically by AI, and I did not receive any sort of email, to know the bad actors who were behind this. I can’t even do a counter claim.

Expected behavior

I should receive an email to know who the bad actor was that sent this false DMCA claim, so I can counter it.

email example:

And things like these should never be automated, as horrible things have happened in the past seen in DevForum posts below:

DMCA Report Against Other Users Wrongly Took Down My Own Assets

Apologies if this is the wrong category, but I saw another post just like this in Bug Reports here, so I inferred that this topic is applicable for this category. I’ve heard from @apoorcarpenter (a Roblox admin) that “there are a lot of edge cases and a lot of legacy code” to the DMCA and rights management processes. This topic is one of those edge cases. I submitted a DMCA takedown notice to Roblox’s copyright agent on 21 July 2025 against multiple Roblox games that were using my game’s icon a…

You are able to DMCA yourself

The title is self explanatory, I attempted to DMCA assets on a group that was stolen from me, and then my account got deleted instead of the group being deleted. [{A30C2FB6-4281-4A8B-AEB3-7A5C395DA40F}] [{B0CC6442-7DA9-453F-9225-10C0265D0D73}] Expected Behavior Your account should NOT be terminated if you delete your own assets off a group, I don’t know how else to explain it… [{F6675FB6-0362-4816-831C-37D4ABA151C3}]

Falsely DMCA striking with decals

As it stands, there is a significant issue with the DMCA process on ROBLOX. Although ROBLOX is committed to diligently reviewing these requests, the current system is not thorough enough to prevent abuse. This flaw allows users to falsely take down others’ accessories. The exploit works as follows: if I upload a screenshot of my accessory and share it, for instance, on a Discord server, a malicious actor can take this screenshot and upload it as a decal on ROBLOX. They then file a DMCA request …

Improvements To DMCA system

As a Roblox developer, it is currently too hard to remove old assets/items I uploaded that might be subject to Copyrighted Material If Roblox is able to address this issue, it would improve my development experience because this would Prevent a LOT of DMCA Issues currently happening on the platform. Right now, Roblox suffers from a LOT of issues related to DMCA System, which can sometimes gets abused, or if used by a company, can falsely Flag items for using names such as “Barbie, Jackson, Jor…

A private message is associated with this bug report

[texturied]

A bad actor also took down one of my top items on an alternate account while abusing DMCA methods. Roblox staff are aware of this situation but they continue to let it happen.

[Arylist]

Was told @apoorcarpenter (Former PM of Rights Manager) no longer works at Roblox, which is quite unfortunate as he used to always help with concerns like these. It feels like ever since he left all the recent DMCA claims have been reviewed by AI and the new team aren’t really aware with what they’re doing. Hope I’m wrong though.

[trigophi]

I’m in the same boat.. and from the same user.

Made around ~300k last week from UGC emotes post-MPF, and now some of my creations have been taken down. Fraudulent groups had also reuploaded content from my friends and me. And those copies are still up…

Not sure how I can proceed, but I’ve already sent a support message with proof of creating my assets. Not sure if this is any use…?

[trigophi]

I’m losing trust in the system lol.. what are the next steps I should take? This was my first time publishing UGC, and it ended up with some DMCA trolling on my uploads

Was sending a support message all I can do for now?

[Arylist]

issue has been resolved privately.