You know full well that this is exactly going to be the vast majority of how this is used.
5 Likes
Interestingly, this was posted after 3 days because the official Roblox channel on YouTube shared it in both standard videos and shorts:
When I reviewed the video, I initially thought it would be a promising resource, enhancing ideas with high-quality models like what you see from other AIs such as Meshy.ai. Analyzing the advertisement, the new feature is far away. Depending on the complexity of what you are looking for, the AI tries to reproduce adding textures, but the topology of the asset doesnât look natural; It feels like a bunch of sculpted decimated geometries:
I understand that this AI has been training a lot based on models that creators like us made through projects and/or are accessible through Creator Store, but I feel like it is not perfect enough to use for experiences if it canât provide models with good texture and optimized topology.
Now, Iâm saying this is all based on the advertisement. With this new announcement, I can test in real-time and make my own prompts to generate models: I started creating prompts such as âRoblox Logoâ, âCybertruckâ, âDavid Baszuckiâ, âFerris Wheelâ and most of them came with appearances that you can say it is 90% odd, bizarre, creepy and 10% is not what you are looking for and it will end up failing to process due to moderation, leaving it to be grey:
Fun fact, the feature will provide the same creation if you use the same prompt instead of creating a variant or at least, another type of mesh with texture. That said if I were to use the same prompt from @IGOBOOM123, I would have the same results:
Overall, it is sadly not powerful enough⌠It consists of having bad creations that will most likely end up being a joke under social media posts such as in Reddit communities.
4 Likes
i like this feature but are we seriously locking it behind id verification (on roblox) when itâs open sourced :l
Definitely⌠like emission maps for SurfaceAppearance!
1 Like
It is not easier to just create a meshpart editor??
1 Like
This is an incredible feature that will surely change how Roblox game development is done.
all the ai tools are amazing but they need to be improved for the tiny details for it to be usable
Donât worry 3d modellers, yâall are safe (for now).
Anyway â with no disrespect to anyone specifically, just the feature â this is overall not a good thing to be made public and a complete disrespect to 3d modelers in my opinion. Resources shouldâve been used elsewhere given the engineâs current state. You (Roblox as a whole) should be encouraging people to create things for themselves instead of generating AI slop and slapping âgame assetâ onto it. At the end of the day, who is even benefitting from this? AI is not the answer to everything. Certainly not for game assets.
29 Likes
I prompted âVikko151â and it gave me this as a result:
Face reveal I guess. 
BONUS: Hereâs the result with something of copyrighted: TF2 scout
1 Like
Cool tech experiment and open source!
But how about fixing bugs that have been around for over 6 years?
Or over 5 years?
Or over 3 years?
Or adding useful engine features?
18 Likes
This is probably where half of the Roblox budget is being spent. Instead of giving us useful features that have we been long waiting for. Such as the comment above
Instead, youâre going to give us some AI tool That may or may not rip the company apart
12 Likes
I appreciate your opinion, but nobody asked. This is meant for users who donât have experience.
Letâs keep our comments non-biased.
4 Likes
By your logic, No one asked if you asked.
5 Likes
Nintendo would like to know your current location.
2 Likes
Aight I just got some questions:
Why is roblox suddenly obfuscating the ID verification part?
Are they aware of the complaints and just trying to hide mentions of it now?
In the past, im pretty sure they have always declared that somewhere on the update post
Why is roblox not optimizing and further improving their platform? Stuff like the forced TextChatService still run like trash, just casually eating up performance
And how can roblox afford to run all this AI stuff? Arenât they just going to lose even more money from this?
2 Likes
WDYM by this? Are you asking why it wasnât clarified in the post? If so, beats me.
Yes
Doubt it, itâs already far too late.
As @Reditect mentioned, probably just different teams.
good question actually 
yeah i do mean the lack of clarification for that first one
but like why canât someone just forcefully motivate that other team into improving the platform, stopping the performance leaks that they themselves forced onto us, and just fix the platform into being semi reliable for once?
1 Like
Did you even look at his post, with all due respect such topology should never be used in any projects, it would only set you up for unoptimized failure, especially those who donât know what theyâre doing.
As previously mentioned it encourages taking the easiest laziest route instead of properly learning the basics to get better results, it removes incentive to learn the bare minimum, following this route you will rarely ever find any success and sooner or later youâll need to learn the basics of these skills regardless, all this does is prolong that realization process for new developers
5 Likes
i swear the ai is going to misread one of my prompts and get my account deletedâŚ
no thank you.
2 Likes
With all due respect, itâs my opinion, of course itâs going to be biased. Inexperienced individuals have online resources to become experienced. I wonât be responding further 
1 Like